Better Living Through Blogging!

Tasteless - For Now?

Over at MeFi, there's a thread about a LiveJournal (LJ) site presented from the point of view of -- brace yourself -- Anne Frank. You know -- LJ sites are often considered "diaries," so someone figured it would be amusing (?) to do an LJ site of Anne Frank's diary, arguably the most famous diary in history. So there it is: The LiveJournal of Anne Frank. The problem: it's truly tasteless, and you are hereby warned that it will likely offend you. In fact, many would consider it blasphemous, sacreligious, disgusting, or worse. But...

You know, I don't think anyone would condemn someone who perished in, say, the Salem witch trials. After all, that happened hundreds of years ago; there is no one alive now who has firsthand knowledge of the Salem incident. An LJ diary of a "witch" presented in this manner would likely either be ignored, or enjoyed by a very small group of people. I seriously doubt anyone would condemn it, or even call it "tasteless."

My guess is that because, relatively speaking, Anne Frank is still fresh in our memory, it IS considered tasteless and condemned. In other words -- there are still people alive in our world who lived through the Holocaust/WWII/etc. It's possible (don't know) that there are still people alive who KNEW Anne Frank.

And what this person is doing is arguably no more offensive than, say, The Onion; some of their stuff is very, very rough, too ("Reagan's Body Dies" and "Nancy Reagan Available At 82" for instance).

I think that time is the key here. In perhaps 100 or 200 years, this won't seem quite as bad. But for now - bad taste, and probably worthy of contempt.